I hate Captchas

will posted 08/05/08 @ 12:00PM EST

Prove you're human. This three word idea gets more and more infuriating with each passing idea. Captcha is the name of the system where you have to decipher skewed letters to prove that you are not an automated machine leaving spam. The problem: it's becoming an arms race; people are cracking these, and they have to make it harder.

Uploaded file

I'm far from the first person to write about this, but it pisses me off. The comic above doesn't emulate my feelings toward seeing that message, but it's funny nonetheless. In my eyes, the only people who lose are the people who want to leave comments, but can't, and as a result, the writers who lose satisfaction when they see less people commenting. I suppose this affects people with poorer vision, but I have 20/15 vision, and I still mess them up.

Uploaded file

As you can see in the above picture with the kitty captcha, they're becoming even more creative, which again, is not a good thing for us. The captcha which bested me, leading me to write this, wasn't anything special but it annoyed me and is shown below. I vow that I will never include captchas here on Will and Beyond.

Uploaded file

I have a system where when a comment comes up, I can select part of the text, and add that to my spam filter, then any future comments which contain that string will be deleted. I'm careful to make sure and only mark really spammy phrases, that no commenter would ever write. It's a little extra work, but it ensures that nobody is turned away by these evil Captchas.

Godspeed.


This posted tagged as: ranting

Recent posts tagged as ranting:
#1: by Osama on 08/05/08 @ 1:04PM EST

Brilliant! I hate Captchas too! And you just gave me an idea ...

Reply to this comment.
#2: by Steamykitchen on 08/06/08 @ 11:10AM EST

i hate captchas too. evil evil evil things because I always get them wrong.

Reply to this comment.
Name:


Website:


Enter a valid email:

(Gravatars and retaggr profiles are supported.)

Receive notification of followup comments?
Yes No

Comment:
(First time commenters: Don't post links or you'll be flagged as spam.)


Reply to main post. (To reply to an individual comment, select it above.)